Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • Our Story
    • Partner with us
    • Reach Us
    • Career
    Subscribe Newsletter
    HR KathaHR Katha
    • Exclusive
      • Exclusive Features
      • Perspectives
      • Friday Features
      • herSTORY
      • Rising Stars
      • Case-In-Point
      • Point Of View
      • Research
      • HR Pops
      • Dialogue
      • Movement
      • Profile
      • Beyond Work
      • By Invitation
    • Brief News
      • Global HR News
      • Compensation & Benefits
      • Diversity
      • Events
      • Gen Y
      • Hiring & Firing
      • HR & Labour Laws
      • Learning & Development
      • Merger & Acquisition
      • Performance Management & Productivity
      • Talent Management
      • Tools & Technology
      • Work-Life Balance
    • Special
      • Editorial
      • HR Forecast 2026
      • Cover Story
      • HR Forecast 2024
      • HR Forecast 2023
      • HR Forecast 2022
      • HR Forecast 2021
      • HR Forecast 2020
      • HR Forecast 2019
      • New Age Learning
      • Coaching and Training
      • Learn-Engage-Transform
    • Studio
      • The CHRO Playbook
      • Quick HR Insights
      • The Corner Office
    • Reports
      • Whitepaper
        • HR Forecast 2024 e-mag
        • Future-proofing Manufacturing Through Digital Transformation
        • Employee Healthcare & Wellness Benefits: A Guide for Indian MSMEs
        • Build a Future Ready Organisation For The Road Ahead
        • Employee Experience Strategy
        • HRKatha 2019 Forecast
        • Decoding and Driving Employee Engagement
        • One Platform, Infinite Possibilities
      • Survey Reports
        • Happiness at Work
        • Upskilling for Jobs of the Future
        • The Labour Code 2020
    • Forums
      • HRKatha Inner Circle
      • HRKatha Futurecast
      • Leadership Summit 2025
      • Rising Star Leadership Awards
      • HRKatha Futurecast 2025
      • Automation.NXT
      • The Great HR Debate
    WhatsApp LinkedIn X (Twitter) Facebook Instagram
    HR KathaHR Katha
    Home»Exclusive Features»‘Overqualified’ does not necessarily mean ‘smart’
    Exclusive Features

    ‘Overqualified’ does not necessarily mean ‘smart’

    mmBy Puja Bothra | HRKathaFebruary 26, 2019Updated:February 27, 20195 Mins Read21813 Views
    Share LinkedIn Twitter Facebook WhatsApp
    Share
    LinkedIn Twitter Facebook WhatsApp

    An overqualified employee is as bright as a button, but is this button hanging loose and ready to fall? Highly educated people possessing a degree in each pocket consent to take up jobs that do not require much in terms of qualification, simply because there is a dearth of job opportunities in the market.

    HRKatha had reported a few months back that in Uttar Pradesh, a surprising number of PhD holders (3700) had applied for peon vacancies. These posts, for messengers, were advertised by the Uttar Pradesh Police, stating the required qualification as Class V.

    “Today, even for a constable’s post you will have a PhD holder applying because it is easily available in some universities for a sum. People are misguided into thinking that higher and multiple degrees will improve their job prospects,” remarks S Ramesh Shankar, EVP, head-HR, South Asia, Siemens.

    Overqualified employees often compromise and settle for low-paying jobs that are not challenging. They are too big for the pond size and that makes them restless, unstable and a threat. A company is unable to exploit their potential, which leads to increasing stress levels and frustration in these employees. They don’t stick around for long and are responsible for taking the attrition rate up.

    Ramesh Shankar S

    “Today, even for a constable’s post you will have a PhD holder applying because it is easily available in some universities for a sum. People are misguided into thinking that higher and multiple degrees will improve their job prospects”

    If the highest qualified resources develop without differentiated performance, companies harm themselves. These resources develop negative attitudes, such as a sense of entitlement with regard to their skills, or resentment through boredom. “Their hubris will become initially self-congratulatory and subsequently self-destructive. Their negative attitude around those less qualified will trigger an air of discontentment that further leads to disengagement. This is bound to adversely impact the organisation’s health and happiness,” says Adil Malia, COO, The Firm.

    They also suffer from financial crises because their salaries are not enough to repay the loans they have taken for higher education.

    The chances of failing for the ‘highest qualified resources’ is as high as that of the just qualified employees—knowledge not being the only success criterion of performance. However, if the mental makeup of the ‘highest qualified resource’ is such that it expects a premium in compensation, benefits and performance merely by virtue of additional qualifications, without displaying differentiated performance, it is the start of a problem,” opines Malia.

    Most good organisations will not shortlist overqualified candidates, but refuse them politely. “In our company, we have employees who pursue higher professional studies, but we do not promote them directly on the basis of just that fact. However, they are free to apply if vacancies arise for senior roles,” says Shankar.

    In the last decade, there has been an extraordinary upswing in the number of individuals opting for higher education in India. The motive behind this is the belief that more the number of degrees, the higher the chance to be financially secure and professionally successful.

    Adil Malia

    “Successful enterprises, therefore, focus on acquiring CRT — compositely right talent and not HQR — highest qualified resource. For successful performance in a role, intellect and intelligence must align. Certification from any knowledge adding factory does not matter!”

    We wonder if this trend is favourable for the employers. Do they benefit from hiring smart, academically qualified individuals or does this result in a backfire?

    “The problem is with our education system. It stresses upon academic prowess rather than skills required for a job. For instance, in countries, such as Germany if you are a carpenter, you take pride in being one. In India, however, being a graduate or a post graduate is a must if you want to make it in life,” opines Shankar.

    “To be able to successfully perform a role, the resource must be ‘competent’ and not necessarily ‘qualified’. Academic knowledge is only one part of competency. There are many other aspects,” reiterates Malia.

    “The relationship between qualifications and jobs needs to be redefined. We need to focus more on vocational education rather than generic education, such as BA/ BSc/ BCom/ MA/ MSc/ MCom. In an engineering company, do we need engineers by qualification? No. We need individuals with application skills who have learned out of passion,” reasons Shankar.

    “Academic qualification is not a true test for talent acquisition. We are slowly gearing up towards putting a ‘test-method’— ‘job-wise screening mechanism’— for the selection process,” continues Shankar.

    “Successful enterprises, therefore, focus on acquiring CRT — compositely right talent and not HQR — highest qualified resource. For successful performance in a role, intellect and intelligence must align. Certification from any knowledge adding factory does not matter!” stresses Malia.

    “Certainly, companies loose out big time when they hire only ‘HQRs’ and I seriously doubt if any company does that,” adds Malia.

    While it is not easy to change the mindsets of people, we are slowly and steadily moving towards differentiating talent from academic prowess.

    Adil Malia employees Job Prospects Jobs Overqualified employees Ramesh Shankar S Recruitment Siemens
    Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook WhatsApp
    mm
    Puja Bothra | HRKatha

    She has been a business writer for a decade now. Besides, she also influences people through motivational workshops. Likes to travel long distances with a book in hand and accounts her travels in a blog. She is very passionate about Yoga and calls it her purpose in life.

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Related Posts

    P&G plans to cut manufacturing and logistics workforce by up to 30% by 2030

    November 20, 2026

    Cisco cuts less than 1% of workforce in latest layoff round

    November 20, 2026

    MP scraps two-child rule for government employees

    November 20, 2026

    Karnataka GCCs employ 43% of India’s AI/ML workforce

    November 20, 2026
    zoha
    Editorial

    Companies owe their people more than what is legal

    When Canva announced a restructuring affecting 1,271 employees, or 22 per cent of its workforce,…

    Hard work built India’s global reputation. Availability cannot define its future

    I must have been in school when I first heard the slogan. I was passing…

    EDITOR'S PICKS

    The career mistakes that don’t look like mistakes

    November 20, 2026

    herSTORY: Surbhi Gupta, Chief Talent Officer, South Asia, Publicis Groupe

    November 19, 2026

    Case-in-Point: When a client wants an employee off the account

    November 19, 2026

    66% of leaders allow AI to write to core systems without approval. Only 33% have fully implemented decision limits

    November 18, 2026
    Latest Post

    P&G plans to cut manufacturing and logistics workforce by up to 30% by 2030

    Brief News November 20, 2026

    Procter & Gamble (P&G) plans to reduce its manufacturing and logistics workforce by 20 to…

    Cisco cuts less than 1% of workforce in latest layoff round

    Brief News November 20, 2026

    Cisco has carried out another round of job cuts in November, affecting less than 1…

    MP scraps two-child rule for government employees

    Brief News November 20, 2026

    The Madhya Pradesh government has approved the removal of its 25-year-old two-child restriction for government…

    Karnataka GCCs employ 43% of India’s AI/ML workforce

    Brief News November 20, 2026

    Karnataka’s Global Capability Centres (GCCs) employ 43 per cent of India’s GCC-based artificial intelligence and…

    Asia's No.1 HR Platform

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn WhatsApp Bluesky
    • Our Story
    • Partner with us
    • Career
    • Reach Us
    • Exclusive Features
    • Cover Story
    • Editorial
    • Dive into the Future of Work: Download HRForecast 2024 Now!
    © 2026 HRKatha.com
    • Disclaimer
    • Refunds & Cancellation Policy
    • Terms of Service

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.