A driver employed by the Telangana State Road Transport Corporation (TSRTC) was retired before time as he was diagnosed with colour blindness. The said driver, Joseph was appointed in 2014. During a routine medical enquiry, he was declared to be no longer fit for the job as he was found to be colour blind. The TSRTC ordered for him to be retired from service. His request for an alternate job was rejected too. The Telangana High Court, however, ruled in favour of TSRTC, and ordered Joseph to make representation to seek his benefits.
When Joseph appealed to the Supreme Court, he referred to a 1979 MOS as per which he was entitled to alternate employment and related benefits. However, TSRTC maintained that the 1979 MOS was revised and allowed for suitable alternate job to be given only wherever possible; and that in Joseph’s case it wasn’t possible as he wasn’t literate or qualified.
The Supreme Court observed that even though Joseph was keen to take up an alternate job, TSRTC had made no visible effort to look for a feasible job for him. Also colour blindness made him unfit as a driver but he could have been easily assigned a non-driving role. As per the Supreme Court, all alternatives should have been explored and exhausted before retiring a person on medical grounds. By not doing so, TSRTC had actually violated Joseph’s right to livelihood and equal treatment. Stating that ‘Employer’s discretion ends where employee’s dignity begins,’ the Supreme Court ruled in favour of Joseph. He will be reinstated in a non-driving role and also be paid his wage arrears for the period he was without job.
The decision was delivered by a bench comprising Justices J K Maheshwari and Aravind Kumar. The ruling enforced the fact that employers are constitutionally obligated to accommodate employees who happen to develop or acquire a disability during service.


