Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • Our Story
    • Partner with us
    • Reach Us
    • Career
    Subscribe Newsletter
    HR KathaHR Katha
    • Exclusive
      • Exclusive Features
      • Research
      • Point Of View
      • Case In Point
      • Dialogue
      • Movement
      • Profile
      • Beyond Work
      • Rising Star
      • By Invitation
    • News
      • Global HR News
      • Compensation & Benefits
      • Diversity
      • Events
      • Gen Y
      • Hiring & Firing
      • HR & Labour Laws
      • Learning & Development
      • Merger & Acquisition
      • Performance Management & Productivity
      • Talent Management
      • Tools & Technology
      • Work-Life Balance
    • Special
      • Cover Story
      • Editorial
      • HR Forecast 2024
      • HR Forecast 2023
      • HR Forecast 2022
      • HR Forecast 2021
      • HR Forecast 2020
      • HR Forecast 2019
      • New Age Learning
      • Coaching and Training
      • Learn-Engage-Transform
    • Magazine
    • Reports
      • Whitepaper
        • HR Forecast 2024 e-mag
        • Future-proofing Manufacturing Through Digital Transformation
        • Employee Healthcare & Wellness Benefits: A Guide for Indian MSMEs
        • Build a Future Ready Organisation For The Road Ahead
        • Employee Experience Strategy
        • HRKatha 2019 Forecast
        • Decoding and Driving Employee Engagement
        • One Platform, Infinite Possibilities
      • Survey Reports
        • Happiness at Work
        • Upskilling for Jobs of the Future
        • The Labour Code 2020
    • Conferences
      • HRKatha Futurecast
      • Automation.NXT
      • The Great HR Debate
    • HR Jobs
    WhatsApp LinkedIn X (Twitter) Facebook Instagram
    HR KathaHR Katha
    Home»Exclusive Features»How layoffs can backfire
    Exclusive Features

    How layoffs can backfire

    mmBy Kartikay Kashyap | HRKathaJuly 11, 2019Updated:July 11, 20196 Mins Read18078 Views
    Share LinkedIn Twitter Facebook
    Share
    LinkedIn Twitter Facebook

    Layoffs are not really a strategy, but an option resorted to when a company is not doing well or in other words, when an organisation is not making profits. Layoffs work as first aid administered to an injured person — something that is applied when companies are bleeding. But do they really help the companies to recover or revive?

    Several researches and analyses have taken place to prove that layoffs do not help organisations in any way to boost their profits. Many myths are attached to layoffs.

    1. Increase in productivity: People think layoffs help increase the productivity of the company, as they help cut flab and make the company leaner. But a study conducted by Wharton professor, Peter Cappelli, found that while labour cost decreases during downsizing, sales per employee also goes down.

    2. Reduction in cost: Another myth is that layoffs help cut costs. However, there is no logical reason to support this. A research conducted by professor Wayne Cascio of the University of Colorado lists some direct and indirect costs associated with layoffs. These include severance pay; paying out accrued vacation and sick pay; outplacement costs; higher unemployment-insurance taxes; the cost of rehiring employees when business improves; low morale and risk-averse survivors’ potential lawsuits and sabotage.

    The research by Cascio also mentions that IBM had to spend 700 million dollars on employee restructuring in 2007 and Microsoft spent around 1.6 billion dollars during a mass downsizing activity in 2014 when they laid off 18000 employees.

    3. Increase in profitability: Yet another myth that exists is that by cutting costs through downsizing, there will be an increase in the profitability of a company. This is also not true. A study of 122 companies found that downsizing further reduces the profitability of a company and the most affected are the organisations in the R&D intensive sectors. Cascio’s study of firms in the S&P 500 also established that companies which downsized remained less profitable than the ones that did not.

    Ramesh Shankar S

    “Nowadays companies tend to measure profits on a short-term basis rather than focusing on the long-term impacts. Whenever they witness losses in back to back quarters, the shareholders and investors pressurise the management to take some major steps. Hence, they resort to laying off people as a short-term remedy rather than thinking about the long-term impact. I think it is foolish to do so. Layoffs should be the last option”

    Another survey by the American Management Association on the companies’ own perceptions of layoffs reported that half the companies did not see any increase in operating profits and one third did not see any positive impact on the productivity of the workers.

    “We cannot say that layoffs can increase the profitability of a company. It only helps to reduce the losses by cutting costs,” says Ramesh Shankar S, former EVP and head, HR, Siemens.

    Amit Das, director and CHRO, Bennet & Coleman, adds, “It certainly reduces the fixed cost in the short term but the implications arising out of the negative internal and external environment, impact on reputation and goodwill, low morale and productivity, make the objective of ensuring profitability in a sustained manner extremely difficult.”

    At the end of it all, we are still left with one question — Are layoffs necessary? Isn’t there another way to come out of bad times?

    Let us take a classic example of an airline company which has never laid off a single employee in 40 to 45 years, that is, since its inception. Southwest Airlines, a US based company did not lay off a single employee even during the great recession period when many of its competitors were ‘forced’ to do so.

    Experts say that no company wants a layoff to happen and it is a last option. But how did Southwest manage to avoid it?

    Amit Das

    “Layoffs certainly reduces the fixed cost in the short term but the implications arising out of the negative internal and external environment, impact on reputation and goodwill, low morale and productivity, make the objective of ensuring profitability in a sustained manner extremely difficult”

    According to Shankar, in a manufacturing industry, material cost sums up to around 60-70 per cent of the total cost, and the cost of human resource is only 5 to 10 per cent.

    “Nowadays companies tend to measure profits on a short-term basis rather than focusing on the long-term impacts. Whenever they witness losses in back to back quarters, the shareholders and investors pressurise the management to take some major steps. Hence, they resort to laying off people as a short-term remedy rather than thinking about the long-term impact. I think it is foolish to do so. Layoffs should be the last option,” opines Shankar.

    Shankar suggests that rather than laying off people companies should look to minimise the major costs, which can differ from sector to sector. And if not fulltime employees, organisations can hire part-time, third-party or contractual employees to reduce the impact of unemployment.

    Some may still argue that during layoffs mostly underperformers and disgruntled employees are targeted, which allows the organisations to increase productivity while claiming to have a positive effect on the corporate culture. But the fact remains that you cannot expect productivity from the remaining employees as their morale is already down and some may also be deeply affected by the thought of losing their friends and co-workers.

    Hari T.N

    “Companies can and should use these opportunities to clean up and take the tough calls. Good times often lead to bad management practices because they tend to get hidden, and bad times force companies to review their bad practices and clean up”

    “Such actions taken only during the layoff time will have no positive impact on corporate culture if not the reverse. We cannot expect to go for interior decoration when the house is on fire”. Nevertheless, a well-structured identification process backed by robust communication and adequate support during exit process helps to reduce the pain and the inevitable negative impact on the organisation’s reputation, besides low internal employee morale,” advises Das.

    Hari T.N, head-HR, BigBasket, adds, “Companies can and should use these opportunities to clean up and take the tough calls. Good times often lead to bad management practices because they tend to get hidden, and bad times force companies to review their bad practices and clean up.”

    Amit Das Big Basket cut costs Hari T.N last resort Layoff profitability Ramesh Shankar S Siemens Southwest Airlines Times of India
    Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook
    mm
    Kartikay Kashyap | HRKatha

    A mass communication graduate Kartikay is a quick learner. A fresh bake, yet a prolific writer, he is always keen to learn and discover new things. He is an easy going gallivanted and just likes to chill out when he is not chasing news. He loves watching movies as well.

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    twenty − 12 =

    Related Posts

    The quiet commute: How a digital detox is reshaping work-life balance

    May 16, 2025

    HSBC to cut over 340 jobs in France as part of global cost-cutting strategy

    May 15, 2025

    “Dark factories still a decade away from disrupting India’s employment market,” Sushil Baveja, CHRO, Jindal Stainless

    May 15, 2025

    How Pramerica Life builds an ethical culture that works

    May 15, 2025
    EDITOR'S PICKS

    The quiet commute: How a digital detox is reshaping work-life balance

    May 16, 2025

    “Dark factories still a decade away from disrupting India’s employment market,” Sushil Baveja, CHRO, Jindal Stainless

    May 15, 2025

    How Pramerica Life builds an ethical culture that works

    May 15, 2025

    Red flags in job applications: What candidates miss but recruiters spot

    May 14, 2025
    Latest Post

    Maxme launches human skills programmes to future-proof India’s workforce

    News May 16, 2025

    As India ramps up efforts to prepare its workforce for a rapidly-evolving professional landscape, the…

    Aviation Ministry introduces transition plan for Celebi’s 10,000 employees

    News May 16, 2025

    The Ministry of Civil Aviation has initiated a comprehensive transition plan to ensure that approximately…

    SC orders West Bengal to pay 25% DA to state employees

    News May 16, 2025

    In a significant development, the Supreme Court has directed the West Bengal government to pay…

    Andhra Pradesh govt eases employee transfer ban till 2 June

    News May 16, 2025

    The State government of Andhra Pradesh has announced a temporary relaxation of the ban on…

    Asia's No.1 HR Platform

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn WhatsApp Bluesky
    • Our Story
    • Partner with us
    • Career
    • Reach Us
    • Exclusive Features
    • Cover Story
    • Editorial
    • Dive into the Future of Work: Download HRForecast 2024 Now!
    © 2025 HRKatha.com
    • Disclaimer
    • Refunds & Cancellation Policy
    • Terms of Service

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.