In India’s bustling and deeply-layered linguistic landscape, where a language isn’t just a means of communication but a badge of identity, two recent incidents have struck a raw nerve. In Karnataka, a State Bank of India (SBI) employee refused to speak in Kannada with a customer, leading to public outrage, political intervention, and an apology. In Maharashtra, an Airtel store employee declined to converse in Marathi, sparking similar backlash. These moments, caught on camera and shared widely, were not mere customer service missteps—they were cultural flashpoints. They have now sparked urgent conversations in boardrooms about the importance of language sensitivities, workplace diversity, and the fine art of balancing regional pride with national unity.
But what do these linguistic tensions reveal about India Inc.’s hiring practices, employee training, and brand identity? And how can HR leaders bridge the gap between linguistic pride and operational pragmatism?
Hiring for connection, not just communication
Raj Narayan, senior HR leader, offers a clear directive: organisations should aim to hire employees proficient in at least two languages—one being Hindi or English, and the other, the regional language of the location. “It’s not about ticking a box. It’s about honouring the customer’s comfort zone,” he says, going on to explain, “When you speak a customer’s native tongue, you don’t just inform—you connect.”
“It’s not about ticking a box. It’s about honouring the customer’s comfort zone. When you speak a customer’s native tongue, you don’t just inform—you connect.”
Raj Narayan, senior HR leader
Agreeing and adding nuance, Pradyumna Pandey, another HR leader, states, “Language proficiency must be mandatory in customer-facing roles. When a customer walks into a store or bank and can’t communicate, it erodes trust. For back-end roles, however, linguistic diversity should be welcomed over uniformity.”
Organisations often view diversity only through the lens of gender. True workplace diversity, however, must account for language, region and religion as well. That’s what gives people confidence that every identity is respected.”
Language and the confidence crisis
Pandey also raises an important point about the dominance of English in corporate India—“Many employees hesitate to share ideas simply because they’re not fluent in English. That silences innovation and collaboration.”
“Language proficiency must be mandatory in customer-facing roles. When a customer walks into a store or bank and can’t communicate, it erodes trust. For back-end roles, however, linguistic diversity should be welcomed over uniformity.”
Pradyumna Pandey, senior HR leader
This is where both Pandey and Narayan see training and onboarding playing a transformative role. Narayan recommends onboarding modules that don’t just inform employees about company policies but also instil values of empathy and linguistic respect. “Even simple role-plays and simulations—teaching people how to respond when they can’t speak a customer’s language—can build emotional intelligence,” he believes.
Local language in customer-facing roles: A non-negotiable
Chandrasekhar Mukherjee, senior HR leader, echoes this sentiment with urgency. “You have to be sensitive to where an employee is posted. Language is not just a tool—it’s an emotional bridge.” He cites real-world challenges, such as sending a non-Hindi-speaking employee to a rural area in North India or a non-Marathi speaker to rural Maharashtra. “It’s not just about language—it’s about understanding the entire cultural ecosystem.”
“You have to be sensitive to where an employee is posted. Language is not just a tool—it’s an emotional bridge.”
Chandrasekhar Mukherjee, senior HR leader
He recalls how, in the past, organisations that posted employees to culturally distinct areas would sensitise them to local customs and dress codes. “If you’re sending a woman to a traditional area in Rajasthan, she needs to know about local expectations, such as the parda system. This is not about judgment; it’s about respect,” he shares. The same principle applies to language.
Furthermore, Pandey believes technology can help bridge this gap. To democratise learning and foster inclusion, he suggests turning to AI-based training modules in regional languages. He also recommends tracking language representation in hiring—“Knowing what percentage of your workforce speaks which language helps create psychological safety and belonging,” he advises.
Striking a balance: Localisation vs. meritocracy
A key challenge lies in balancing regional identity with inclusive hiring. Can a company demand Kannada proficiency in Karnataka without being discriminatory?
Narayan believes it can—if done thoughtfully. According to him, “Regional language skills should be framed as a business requirement for specific roles, not a blanket rule.” He suggests a 50-50 staffing model in customer-facing environments—half of the staff should speak the local language fluently, while the others add linguistic diversity.
This model has already been adopted by companies in telecom, hospitality and retail, especially in tier-2 and tier-3 cities. “It ensures that someone is always available to bridge the gap, without excluding talent from other regions,” says Narayan.
The role of emotional intelligence and adaptability
Mukherjee warns that linguistic fluency alone will not prevent conflict. “These flare-ups aren’t always about words—they’re about ego. A small misunderstanding becomes a power struggle, and suddenly, it’s viral.” His advice is simple: Even if you are in an elite Nariman Point branch in Mumbai, you’ll have customers who speak only Gujarati or Marathi. You may be Tamilian or Punjabi—but you should be willing to learn a few local phrases, be polite and genuinely helpful.
He recalls how foreign professionals used to undergo cultural sensitivity training before working in India. “They were taught to greet women with a ‘namaste’ instead of a handshake. That’s how deeply gestures matter.”
The lesson? A little adaptability goes a long way. Even in metro cities, employees must be willing to learn basic phrases in local languages, show politeness, and approach customers with empathy.
Creating a culture of linguistic respect
Narayan believes that nurturing linguistic respect is a shared responsibility. “It’s not just an HR issue—it’s a leadership imperative.” He suggests that leaders model inclusive behaviour, reinforcing it through regular sensitisation programmes, communication guidelines and feedback mechanisms.
He also recommends recognising inclusive behaviour as part of performance reviews. “We celebrate innovation and performance—why not reward cultural sensitivity? Similarly, repeated exclusionary behaviour should have consequences,” he points out.
Localisation without alienation
Should customer-facing brands localise their language policies? “Absolutely—but with care,” Narayan affirms. “Localisation doesn’t mean exclusion. It means being smart about how we organise teams, structure shifts and train people.”
He suggests that in metro cities and regions with high migration, localisation could be implemented in zones or shifts so that every shift has people who know the local language along with others from diverse regions. For instance, a bank branch in Chennai could have a mix of Tamil, Hindi and English speakers working collaboratively. This also mirrors India’s urban demographic reality, where people from all corners of the country live and work together.
He also notes the importance of internal mobility programmes—where employees from different regions are given basic language training when posted to new locations. “This is already happening in PSU banks and some government-run entities,” he adds.
Bridging policy and practice: HR must lead the charge
Mukherjee places the onus squarely on HR and senior leadership. “You cannot post someone to a region where they can’t communicate. If language is a barrier, soft skills must compensate—and not just minimally, but powerfully.”
He shares an example from the print media industry, where local hires were the norm: “In Mumbai, you hired a Tamilian for Chembur, a Gujarati for Ghatkopar, and a Maharashtrian for Dadar—because connection precedes conversion.”He cautions against ignoring this in formal sectors as well. “Posting a non-Hindi-speaking person to Pune’s rural branches without support is setting them up to fail, unless they’re exceptionally empathetic and adaptive.”
Narayan reminds us that in India, language is identity. “When you disrespect someone’s language, you disrespect their history, their culture, and their sense of self.” The challenge for modern organisations, then, is not to homogenise—but to harmonise; to create workspaces where every employee, regardless of mother tongue, feels heard; where every customer, regardless of location, feels valued.
In a country as rich and diverse as India, that’s no small task. However, with inclusive hiring, thoughtful training, and a deep cultural commitment, it’s not just possible—it’s imperative.
49 Comments
Hindi should be taught as a mandatory language in each and every state. Period. Problem solved.
Don’t you have basic common sense?
The only mistake the Manager did was she did not direct the Customer to a Kanada speaking bank employee. So the mistake lies with both the Customer and Manager.
Because north india are thought hindi from birth ,they are confidently asking hindi to be made compulsory every where,they are intimidated by other langauge,even south Indian may also feel the same when they are made to speak other languages, but all south Indians know hindi as they know when they go to North they need this langauge, but the north Indians do not make effort to learn local langauge and really dominate.they also show the edited version of the fight,they edit the version where they were disrespectful.
Body language of manager triggered the problem. A higher position demands more patience, soft attitude.
Be a Roman when in Rome.
Kannada should be made mandatory language all across North Indian schools as they have beg and come down to Karnataka for livelihood.. Thats it
I am a Tamil from TN. Learnt Tamil and English at school. Came to Bangalore for work and learnt Kannada myself. i am fluent in Kannada, Tamil and English now. I have no use for Hindi. Why should I learn it? Don’t thrust Hindi on those you don’t need it. Mother tongue for home and English for the world is more than enough. Whoever needs it can learn any language, including Hindi, when they need it. This Hindi only policy make Hindi people arrogant and non-hindi people as second class. Time to bring construction amendment and stop Hindi imposition. Two languages is enough in schools.
There is a relevance between Kannada language and Tamil, that’s why its fast to learn for a Tamil, Telgu, Malayalam people.
U will understand if u go to some other state leaving TN, Karnataka, how hindi is important. Go to UP, Bihar or any state in North India with ur Tamil, Kannada and English proficiency and not to learn Hindi mind set. U will not go or can’t go & stay there because u can only be comfortable staying ur comfort zone state.
For ur kind information hindi is not the national language
No. You can learn German to go to Germany and French to go to France but not the local language of a state?
Why? Are Indian regional languages somehow inferior?
No problem is solved by this nonsensical concept of Hindi assimilation.
Exactly…if you are true indian respect all stare languages of India.Dint just enjoy the city be a part of it. Connect with people by showing respect to the perticular state culture and their emotions about their state language. Just don’t say I will not speak Kannada or ……instead try to learn. This ” Kannada Gotthilla” is not cute or joke anymore…it’s a choice..if you can learn German or French you can also learn Kannada. Learning Kannada and showing respect to the culture is also showing the respect to a Bangalore city founder and builder, the great Kannadiga Kempegowda …don’t just enjoy the city be a part of it when you choose to live, establish your business and earn from the Karnataka.
Thank you,
Jsi Hind , Jsi Karnataka
Exactly…if you are true indian respect all stare languages of India.Dint just enjoy the city be a part of it. Connect with people by showing respect to the perticular state culture and their emotions about their state language. Just don’t say I will not speak Kannada or ……instead try to learn. This ” Kannada Gotthilla” is not cute or joke anymore…it’s a choice..if you can learn German or French you can also learn Kannada. Learning Kannada and showing respect to the culture is also showing the respect to a Bangalore city founder and builder, the great Kannadiga Kempegowda …don’t just enjoy the city be a part of it when you choose to live, establish your business and earn from the Karnataka.
Thank you,
Jai Hind , Jai Karnataka
Correct
Agreed
The public dealing employees not knowing the local language should not be arbitrarily transferred to such postings as conversing in local language is not easy even when employee sincerely tries. Forcing him to speak a particular language if not convercent, may create further problems. The attitude of management to send employees and then forget however high the employee tries for transfer, should also change.
Saurabh Malhotra comment is insensitive and shows cow belt culture.
Hindi should be taught? No we don’t want to learn Hindi
Hindi is not our mother tongue it’s absolute discrimination with other languages
It is idiotic what’s going on in the name of language, central govt and bank employees can be transferred to any state its unrealistic to expect every body to know every language, all this talk of connecting with customer is utopian talk, customer wants his work to be done in any language.
Best have native people local people are enough why do they need non native people makes no sense we don’t want diversity but local people who can connect preserve and respect culture
The issue is not about language but about being superior and treating others as inferior, I myself have faced this issue, I am with the bank manager kannada people always discriminate people speaking hindi language and its a propoganda spreading through politics in order to get votes. People are misguided and in this case too everyone accused the bank manager but please at least the bank should stand with its manager but they didn’t, I have closed all the 5 account in SBI bank for their mistake. If you don’t believe go kannada and speak Hindi you will soon understand what I mean and why I am with that manager.
No.
When a bank employee sends you back because your pen broke and they couldn’t be bothered to share theirs, customers feel superior?
When a bank manager insults you because you came to deposit an amount but made a mistake on denominations on the challan and are willing to rewrite it, its because of customer’s ego?
When a customer-facing bank manager refuses to provide services because she believes she is a position of prestige, it’s the bank manager who feels superior.
Yes, it is an issue of ego. And these managers have egos larger than the country.
I’m a bank manager in baliya up or Amethi or even gurugram. I only speak kannada or English. Challenge you there will be a riot. It’s mot needed to speak hindi every where. I have experienced not as a manager but in a private company in Noida. I leftvthe job and returned to mumbai in six months. Starting is always hindi or Bhojpur or openly insulting english speakers. Go to up offices in Lucknow you will realize.no hi di mo communication. I believe customer is always right. Arrogance has nonplace in service I dustdy. I stand with the customer I appreciate the bank and thank karnataka politicians to prevent that fraud manager continuing
Agreed
That is why English was considered the Lingua Franca of India. Not a state language and no bruised egos. They can go and do their politicking in other spheres. Leave banks and government offices to do their work in peace. They are all already overloaded with holidays cropping up every week. When does any work get done. With these regional, sectional, religious, cultural holidays, one waits weeks for work which could be done in 2 days. Get with it India. See how efficiently other countries work, despite having many languages. Learn from better models world- wide. Don’t think India has the best ones, because we clearly don’t. A workplace is for work not cultural egos.
Why don’t you atleast use English… You wld not expect anyone to speak in kannada Or tamil when you are in a hindi speaking state… You wld rather start learning n speaking in hindi.. But why insist to speak only in ur language when you are here in a South Indian state… When we are in Delhi or somewhere in the North- we are
supposed to speak in ur language, in this case hindi… N when you are in our place, here also we are expected to speak in ur language…u won’t even try to learn the local language..wah….supremacy I feel…
You learn your mugjal language. India is not single entity
Lol then your ilk goes to muslim area and apologise for asking them to speak the vernacular instead of mughal language and what about English, eh? Is your father some old Englishman for English to be fine with you mofoz?
Many customers can converse only in the local regional language. How will a front end employee converse with such a person if he/ she does not know the local language. It will be frustrating for the customer.
We should respect our national language too.
In this particular case of this SBI Mabager, the root cause was not really the language but her arrogance and extremely rude behavior with the customer. If only she said “Sorry, I don’t know Kannada” the matter might have been different. But she was too rude and the way she spoke, even others could get angry with her. It is important that everyone knows their own position and behave appropriately.
Finding a common language as a mere communication tool is a basic need. By fueling debates the perception that this need is changing to giving respect to each other’s language and culture is just a politically driven ideology. It’s dangerous and needs to stop. People visiting other states for short duration are bearing the brunt. No culture in India teaches animosity towards other cultures. Infact it teaches how to welcome differences and live harmoniously. What’s happening in Maharashtra and Karnataka is just too demeaning for this cultures. Do not fan it.
This issue is being faced by customers also who do not know the local language. How insensitive can customer care employees be when they assume that the customer knows local language while initiating a conversation. That is why treat language as a only a communication tool and nothing else.
The solution lies in making provision of extra payment or allowance for personnel working in a region other than their home state or to post the personnel in their home state. The extra payment or allowance may encourage them to alteast manage the situation. It is difficult and also punishing on the employees to learn all the languages spoken in different states.
Totally agree, people with customer facing roles should attempt to learn local languages. I know there are some cases of non-kannada speaking folks facing some flak from people here in Bangalore. I am a Bangalorean since birth and can speak in Kannada, Telugu, Sanskrit, Tamil, Hindi and English. But my mother can speak Kannada and Telugu.
There are many instances I have had to choose where to take her and where not because there are enough times the people she have to interact cannot understand her basic interactions like give me water, give me salt, stop on the left, go to next road, my house is near temple not here, give me bigger size, how much is it etc etc. I am sure the folks who come from outside and cannot speak the language the angadi avnu/shop keeper/store wala can/driver/employee of an institution (hospital, hotels, bank, restaurants, mall staff, in some of my friends cases even the apartment community help etc)..
Initially, kannada speaking folks were hired and trained to speak in other languages. But in the last 10-15 years the population demographics have changed people of all walks of life have started to make bengaluru their destination and the city has welcomed them.
By the way this is not the first time in our city’s history. Even in the past people from neighbouring states have come here. But the language barrier is a new thing. It used to just work, people started exchanging languages and also culture. May be there was always some homogenity between the neighbouring state folks and hence it was not difficult. But people from farer land (understood we are in global world) cannot just find reasons to become part, they seem to want to retain their own stuff and also impose it on the folks here. Because of this rigidity a lot of businesses have become unhabitable for both sides of the populations.
I think the solution is very simple,
1) The customer facing role folks in all parts of the city and in all walks of life need to learn multiple languages.
2) the customers (rest of the population) also need to attempt to learn and talk to each other.
Even schools are becoming huge language barrier places.
Soon corporates will use this opportunity to fire Hindi/non Hindi staff and all this will be managed by an AI-ENABLED machines.
India should concentrate in english language like tamilnadu already has 2 language policy tamil for regional and english language to the world . But Government want to force hindi in non Hind belts to benefit the hindi speaking people to give them a job in non Hind belts which is dangerous to regional language speaking people.
Hindi should be made nationsl language officially since we are recognised as people from hindkush valley from ancient times and moreover we call ourselves as hindus or hindustani’s or proudly saying jai hind then why is the problem with hindi language
I would like to contact the writer of this article- Radhika Sharma
U can’t force people to learn any language. It’s our choice. Some have issues in learning languages yet they respect that language. However kannad language is only spoken in KA, rest of India no one knws this language n many haven’t heard of it. KA ppl lack communication n sense as there’s no GK in schools. Anyways Hindi is a common language spoken all over India n unites us. My language is not Hindi yet I speak in Hindi to communicate with other states. Kannad ppl have big tym ego problem they need to work on their skills n GK orelse will be donkeys like this forever hated by 25 states n 8 UTs. U BETTER LEARN HINDI
So this means if I get an African customer or Arabian customer I should talk to him in that language? Does this make any sense? Nonsense people of KA no brains that’s y all BPOs don’t want to give them jobs. Show us 1 Kannada in higher position in any top company? U won’t get to see. U knw y? Coz they r the dumbest ppl n rascists
I’m a bank manager in baliya up or Amethi or even gurugram. I only speak kannada or English. Challenge you there will be a riot. It’s mot needed to speak hindi every where. I have experienced not as a manager but in a private company in Noida. I leftvthe job and returned to mumbai in six months. Starting is always hindi or Bhojpur or openly insulting english speakers. Go to up offices in Lucknow you will realize.no hi di mo communication. I believe customer is always right. Arrogance has nonplace in service I dustdy. I stand with the customer I appreciate the bank and thank karnataka politicians to prevent that fraud manager continuing
When we are going in South, they are charging 11 months of rent in advance. When south India comes in North, we are welcoming these guys. I think now we need to walk up
We should respect our national language too.
There is no national language
Too much drama, pontification and twisting of facts to support linguistic chauvinists. The female Bank Manager was the victim of a goon, whose video recording indicates that he came to the SBI branch with a premeditated motive of specifically targeting the lady. The goon could have conversed with any other person at any of the other counters but his intentions were to draw the female Manager out of her office-cabin to insult her. Why has no legal action been taken against the goon for misconduct with a lady at her place of work. An apology drawn under duress is shameful. I hope some court will take cognizance and bring the goon to face criminal prosecution.
Language based chauvinism in a multi-lingual country like India must stop. No excuses, please.
We need to cut out the nonsense. There are far too many digressionary lectures on this topic by cowards sitting in secure places. The female Bank Manager of SBI in Bangalore was the victim — she was not the one to provoke the mischief. The manner in which the video was recorded, without ever directing the camera to the male, who kept needling the lady at her place of work, very clearly indicates that the incident was premeditated and intended to avoid identification of the goon accosting the respectable lady. The Branch Manager of a bank is usually allotted a cabin and seldom, if ever, sits at a counter. The goon could have conducted his banking business, if any, at any of the appropriate counters, or spoken to any of the other staff fluent in his language. The video clearly discloses a malafide intent to draw out the Branch Manager from her cabin to provoke and to insult her at her place of work. Drawing an apology from the lady under duress was shameful. I wonder why no legal action for criminal misdemeanour with a lady at her place of work has been initiated against the goon, who could surely have been identified by the CCTVs at the bank. Instead, it is being suggested by cowards, ensconced at safe places, that the hapless lady was at fault, ignoring the extreme and totally unnecessary provocation to which she was subjected at her assigned place of work.
This sort of language chauvinism must be strongly deprecated in a multi-lingual country like India. We must regard ourselves as Indians first and belonging to any of the federating States afterwards.
Please arrest the language vigilantes to immediately stop the spread of language chauvinism in India. No excuses, please. Unless stern action is taken, this sordid behaviour will spread to all States in India, tarnishing the fabric of unity in diversity.
The safety of the lady at the SBI branch was seriously compromised by the hoodlum. This is totally unacceptable conduct in civilised India, even if the goon was despatched by a political party to surreptitiously gain political mileage. The lay was targeted!
When corporate Are singing Song to Speak Native Language etc to satisfy customers. But i dont agree threatening peoples to speak Language Compulsory. What is this shit happening she/he is not purchased by you to live in the country. Its their freedom to speak in language they are comfortable. If you have to maintain culture you have to promote and Inform others making a Rally. But instead you go and threaten peoples so they Feel Fear and learn to speak as You Like. Kya gundagiri hi sabhyata Bachana Hota Hain Kya Reh……..
What about people who have transferable jobs?? Do they have to learn a new language, everytime they are transferred to a different state??